Jacob Batalon has sparked renewed speculation about his role in Spider-Man: Brand New Day after posting a photo with a villain-themed action figure. The image quickly spread on social media, prompting fresh theories about his MCU character.

Michael Mando—the actor who first played Mac Gargan in Spider-Man: Homecoming—dropped a behind-the-scenes shot from the Spider-Man: Brand New Day set that’s got Marvel fans convinced a dangerous new chapter for his character is coming.

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has a busy schedule ahead, even if the last few projects haven’t been the biggest hits. Marvel Studios has been talking about slowing down and making fewer movies and shows.