When "Love Island USA" opened up the voting to viewers, many fans were transparent online about breaking up Huda and Jeremiah, who have been locked in since the first episode and haven't explored connections outside of their couple. Huda had deemed her couple "the strongest" in the villa.

Calling the Huda and Jeremiah "my parents in the villa," the 22-year-old dumped Islander gives PEOPLE her take on how closed-off the day 1 couple is